Larry Suffredin is fronting for Fred Barbara on a new landfill in Kankakee.
The company Suffredin keepsLarry Suffredin wants to be the next Cook County state's attorney and says he'd fight corruption. But as a lobbyist, he's been working for a man implicated in a mob bombing
January 30, 2008, BY ERIC HERMAN AND TIM NOVAK Sun-Times Staff reporters
Larry Suffredin -- a
self-styled reformer running for Cook County state's attorney -- lobbied for a landfill controlled by
Fred Bruno Barbara, a businessman once charged with extortion and implicated in the mob bombing of a restaurant, the Sun-Times has learned.
Suffredin, a Cook County commissioner (D-Evanston), has come under attack by rivals for his work as a lobbyist on behalf of casino and drug-company interests. State records show he also lobbied for Kankakee Regional Landfill LLC -- a company tied to Barbara -- in 2005, 2006, and 2007.
More...Freddie "Blue Bag" Barbara is close personal friend of Mayor Daley, a major Daley campaign contributor, and as
Fred Barbara Trucking Co. Inc. also a "consultant"-lobbyist with the local franchise of the national waste management conglomerate
Allied Waste, our home town's $77M/yr garbage hauling and recycling contractor. Chicagoans will be familiar with Fred Barbara's name from
pretty much every article you'll ever read about why Chicago's "blue bag" program is a miserable failure. Followers of the
"Family Secrets" mob trials will recall that there was testimony that
Freddie participated in the bombing of Horwath's Restaurant in Elmwood Park, which was a well-known hangout for mobsters. Barbara is a nephew of the late
Chicago Alderman Fred Roti, who has been
identified by the US Justice Department as a made member of the Chicago mob. More recently, Barbara is behind
the Park Grill restaurant in Millennium Park that for some reason pays no property taxes and gets taxpayer-paid garbage pick-up and gas.
Freddie
formed a partnership with Thomas A. Volini, President of the quaintly-named waste management firm
Town & Country Utilities, Inc. of East Chicago, Indiana (among other diverse firms). Freddie and Tommy called their new partnership
Kankakee Regional Landfill LLC, also, oddly enough, of East Chicago, Indiana.
Barbara, Volini, SuffredinHere's the official online record of Suffredin's hire by Barbara and Volini. You can look it up:
SECRETARY OF STATE LOBBYIST LIST Kankakee Regional Landfill LLC gave the Illinois Secretary of State Department of Business Services as their address of record the address of one of Volini's many companies, Town & Country Utilities:
Town & Country Utilities, Inc.1620 E. CHICAGO AVE.
EAST CHICAGO IN 46312
But when Kankakee Regional Landfill LLC's registered Suffredin as their lobbyist, they gave the Illinois Secretary of State Lobbyist Division the address of a near southwest side property owned by Barbara, which Barbara uses as the address of record of many of his companies:
RIVERVIEW RECYCLING, INC.
Fred Barbara, President
2300 S. ARCHER AVE
CHICAGO, IL 60616
You may recall America's most beloved fictional mob waste management professionals,
The Sopranos, had a particularly brutal episode where a garbage truck crew took a beating from the crew of a rival company's garbage truck over routes. But as Tony later says, "There's plenty of garbage for everyone." And as Mick Dumnke reported recently in the Reader,
there is no shortage of landfills in the Chicago area. The real money is not in the pick-ups, like waiting tables it's in the
tips. If you can tip into your own or a friendly dump, you're golden, but if you have to pay tip fees for someone else's, you're hurting your bottom line big time. And besides,
Ottawa Illinois and
northwestern Indiana are getting sick & tired of our garbage. So Tommy and Freddie hired our very own friendly neighborhood corporate lobbyist Larry Suffredin to help them foist a new dump site on some unsuspecting under-empowered community somewhere.
The future landfill site Barbara and Volini snatched up was not in some obscure corner of
Kankakee County, it is within the southern municipal boundary of the
City of Kankakee, a city of 27,000. They were shopping for a community they could muscle for tax incentives, and they found one. The
Kankakee County Economic Development Council is real excited about the project, to them it looks like jobs. As is
Kankakee Mayor Donald Green (R-Ryan) who happens to be a recipient of campaign contributions from Volini. With little discussion, the Kankakee City Council in August, 2002 obliged by
approving the application for the landfill and, a month later,
extending an "Enterprise Zone" to Barbara's property south of town, making it eligible for lucrative property tax abatements. The
Illinois Pollution Control Board denied the application, so a year later the City Council pushed through a SECOND application, this time including accepting extensive "
findings of fact" cooked up by their hired "expert" to bolster their plan.
There's nothing green about this project except Barbara's and Volini's money. Understand Barbara, Volini and Suffredin were not talking about just Kankakee's own garbage; as the name
Kankakee Regional Landfill LLC implies, the proposal was to accept trash from Illinois and Indiana. And not just residential refuse - a crucial component of their business plan is to accept industrial and construction waste.The people of Kankakee are less than thrilled. They
organized, attended hearings, asked questions, and
hired their own experts. The people who live there know the proposed site is in an
aquifer in the flood plain of the
Iroquois River, which drains into the
Kankakee River. Not ABOVE the aquifer - IN it: they planned to excavate to below the water table, sell the quarried limestone, and then line the 200-acre hole with a plastic sheet to form a "bathtub". Water company
Aqua Illinois takes much of Kankakee County's fresh water from the river a few miles downstream. Many locals hope to revitalize the area by featuring their rivers as a
recreational mecca. Recall earlier this month
the Iroquois flooded its banks, forcing hundreds from their homes in communities along its length, like
Watseka.
The proposed landfill site flooded most recently in 2005.
Suffredin must not be very good lobbyist, because the skids do not appear to be greased very well: his clients are spending an awful lot of time in
court trying to have their way. Suffredin's clients appealed the unfavorable ruling by the
Illinois Pollution Control Board all the way to the
Illinois Supreme Court, trying to force the people of Kankakee to accept their garbage.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF ILLINOIS
TOWN & COUNTRY UTILITIES, INC., et al., Appellees,
v. THE ILLINOIS POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD et al., Appellants.Thankfully, the Supreme Court backed up the experts on our state Pollution Control Board over the so-called "experts" hired by Barbara and Volini.
Meanwhile, unwilling to wait for permit approval, Volini decided to force the issue and simply went ahead and started dumping at the site. Although they had been warned of security guards with shotguns, some brave neighbors photographed a bulldozer scrambling to bury the trash. An
Illinois Environmental Protection inspector, Donna Shehane, was dispatched to the site, and wrote 21 citations for violations of Illinois law. Sheehan's position had been jointly funded by a delegate agreement between the Illinois EPA and Kankakee County Health Department, but shortly after her citation-writing spree the powers that be in Kankakee County eliminated her position, for doing her job too well. Volini's lawyers claimed the IEPA inspector were mistaken, what was dumped (and buried) was not trash but merely "construction materials" being "stored" in anticipation of permit approvals and the infrastructure improvements necessary for the site!
Most recently, our state Attorney General's office is in court trying to collect on the $4,100,000 in resulting fines, and Suffredin's client is, surprise, surprise balking, rejected a settlement offer, and wants a jury trial.
The
Illinois Department of Natural Resources got involved when they noticed Barbara-Volini failed to get a permit from them.
Minnie Creek surrounds the proposed garbage dump on three sides and drains into the Iroquois. After studying the site, IDNR is now requiring a mile-long, 280’ wide relief channel to be dug along the banks of Minnie Creek to handle flood water. Yup, you read that right, the relief channel is not 280' LONG it is a football-field WIDE, all the way around the site. Meanwhile
Volini boasted to the Sun-Times that his permit proves his project is legit.
Volini came back to the Kankakee City Council again and again with one hair-brained scheme after another, arm-in-arm with what he hoped would be a more attractive partner. Next, it's not a regional industrial landfill, it's an
asphalt shingle plant, that just happens to have a landfill nearby to generate methane to power the plant. That fell through after the asphalt shingle plant decided to locate at a far less flood prone site elsewhere in the County. Next, it's not a regional industrial landfill, it's an
ethanol plant, and Volini had Mayor Green shilling for him touting how many millions of bushels of Kankakee County corn he would be buying every year. That fell through, too. The latest scheme is forget the regional garbage, it's just Kankakee municipal waste for now, the permitting process is much simpler, and it's
composting of yard waste.
That his landfill has yet to open is due in no small part to
concerned local citizens, but is also stalled thanks to an unattractive squabble between national waste management giants Allied Waste and Waste Management, and between the City and County of Kankakee. The County does not want to share property tax revenue with the City. Waste Management has teamed with the County on a competing project, just east of the Kankakee Regional Landfill site, on the opposite bank of the Iroquois, on County land outside City limits. The local proxies for Allied and Waste Management are in court trying to slow or stop each other's projects. As Dumnke reported, the
skyrocketing price of diesel is eating into the industry's bottom line, and the attraction here is the proximity to the south Kankakee exit of I-57. Unfortunately, I-57 parallels the Iroquois in southern Kankakee County.
But Suffredin and Barbara and Volini are still fighting the good fight, pushing their second landfill application through the courts. Has Suffredin met his match, lining up against the Illinois EPA, the Pollution Control Board, the Illinois Department of Natural Resources, the Illinois Attorney General, the Illinois Supreme Court, Waste Management, the government of Kankakee County, and the good people of Kankakee County? Time will tell. Even as he runs for Cook County States Attorney, Suffredin continues to represent this client, and hopefully, he'll be back on the case full time Wednesday, February 6.
Suffredin & Volini to the Rescue of the Cook County Hospital Building!But wait, there's more! File
this under "small world."
Using his part-time job as a Cook County Commissioner as leverage, Suffredin arranged for
Volini to take a shot at pitching a plan to save the old Cook County Hospital building to the Cook County Board back in April, 2006. You can look it up. Read the
transcript, it's a hoot. How a career as a waste management executive prepares you to rehab a massive public building, you tell me. Volini himself stated to the County Board that his main qualification was that
"four of his close family members have spent about 40 years working in the old Cook County Hospital building." Uncharacteristically, reason prevailed at the County Board and a developer (
US Equities) with actual experience got a County contract to draft a proposal for the building. But now Suffredin is bragging on being the
savior of the old County Hospital building in his campaign appearances and on his website.
More about Thomas A. Volini: The 48th Ward Democratic Machine Connection
Thomas A. Volini is the brother-in-law of former Chicago Alderman (48th) turned real estate broker Marion Kennedy Volini, and the uncle of her son, former 48th Ward Democratic Committeeman and realtor Michael A. Volini.
Another Indiana-based Volini company,
Midwestern Electric, Inc. had its Illinois business license
revoked by the
Illinois Secretary of State on 1/3/05.
A New Jersey-based Volini company,
Continental Waste Industries, Inc. had its Illinois business license
revoked by the
Illinois Secretary of State on 7/1/96.
The town of Winfield, Indiana was planning to purchase a sewage treatment plant from Volini. Days before the closing, Indiana Department of Environmental Management inspectors
found sewage flowing from a tributary near the plant, which winds its way through Lake George in Hobart, Indiana and eventually flows into
Lake Michigan. Indiana issued a violation letter to Volini. The sale went through a month later, and Indiana is still considering fines against Volini.
And get this: 2001-2002
Volini served on the board of directors of
American Ecology, Inc.,
"the oldest radioactive and hazardous waste services Company in the United States", with former congressman
Dan Rostenkowski. I guess if you are trying to fill out the board of a radioactive and hazardous waste disposal firm, you might have to occasionally call on a few ex-cons.
Suffredin for Cook County Prosecutor? WHA?Let's face it, communities desperate for development, campaign contributions from developers, mobbed-up waste management companies, waste management firms using the courts to enforce their god-given right to site a landfill on their land, are all old stories. But what you
don't expect to find is your own County Commissioner and a candidate for County State's Attorney involved
on the landfill operator's side, for pay.Local corporate lobbyist and part-time Cook County Commissioner Larry Suffredin is currently using union money to run television ads where he looks into the camera and says with a straight face, "As a reformer ... " Will someone please ask him how he squares lobbying for a landfill operator with his progressive reform agenda? Thanks!
Suffredin asks us to
look the other way on his lobbying activities. But you can learn a lot more about Suffredin's
character from looking at the projects he takes on in his day job than you can from his TV spots.
Speaking for myselfIf it was me, I guess I wouldn't run for Cook County Commissioner unless I could be content with the Commssioner's salary, and I guess I wouldn't be seeking outside work unless everything were under control at the County, and there was absolutely nothing else I could possibly be doing for my constituents (not likely).
And I guess if I decided I needed outside income, I don't think I would work as a lobbyist, taking money to influence legislation while also serving as an elected representative of my constituents, lest my constituents get confused.
And I guess if I decided I needed a little something on the side, and I HAD to do it as a lobbyist, and if I had any ideas about higher office, having seen an episode of the Sopranos or two, I think I might take a pass on Italian-American waste management executives knocking on my door seeking help foisting a landfill on a community that doesn't want it.
But that's just me, I guess.